Crime In South Africa Essay
The above statistics are alarming given the focus of resources to these stations. It seems, from the face of it, that the implementation of Presidential Stations is not working even though these stations were prioritised over others. The former MEC for Safety and Security from Limpopo also realised the failure in 2000 and was quoted saying that
In our assessment for the past six months, we have found that the Thohoyandou police station failed to improve in terms of combating crime, instead it is getting worse. At the end, it became the worst in the Vhembe District. They have everything, but they still fail us. If you talk about any type of crime, you get it most in Thohoyandou. We talk about economic crime like burglary, rape, assault with intent to do grievous bodily harm and other crimes; you find them at worst in Thohoyandou.
The MEC was angry with the crime situation in the Presidential station which had all the resources (cars, personnel, and computers) it needed to fight crime and was given preference to others stations. She further noted that other police stations in the area with little resources did better than the Presidential Station (Musetha: 2002). In his budget speech for his department, the MEC for Safety and Security in Mpumalanga conceded that though there were “multi-agency mechanisms structures that were established in the Presidential priority police station of KaNyamazana and the Provincial priority police stations of Vosman and Embalenhle, these structures have not born any fruit” (Pule: 2006).
Crime in South Africa possibly requires a combination both the long term social crime prevention and an effective tough short term law enforcement strategies as was an indication in the NCPS. The only way, however, we can know what actually works, is when there is an implementation tool that works and takes into account the external and internal environments in which these stations operate. These stations seem to have been set up to fail without too to function.
Competing strategies, non-collaboration, unaligned resources, management and the failure to have an implementation framework are all but few variables contributing to crime in the country. It has been argued by Dixon (2000) that a number of models are known but “very little is known about the kind of programmes that work under local conditions” (Dixon: 92). What Dixon is raising is also that strategies should be informed what is happening on the local level, conditions which are determined by how people live and function within those localities. While there is a continuation of scholarly disagreements crime and failing efforts to fight it is a reality. The late Minister Steve Tshwete in 2000 was very optimistic about the government’s strategies to fight crime given that there was a NCPS and Presidential Stations had just been created. In his budget speech to Parliament, he said “the year 2000 will see South Africa's own renaissance in our fight against crime,...
Loading: Checking Spelling0%
Apartheid In South Africa Essay2284 words - 9 pages Segregation is a concept as old as time, and it is not unique to the United States. South Africa still suffers from the effects of an organized and government mandated system of segregation called apartheid that lasted for over a quarter of a century. Apartheid, literally translated from Afrikaans, means apartness (Mandela 40). It is defined as a policy of racial segregation and “political and economic discrimination against...
Gentrification in South Africa Essay833 words - 3 pages Social Segregation in Cities: GentrificationWhat is gentrification?Gentrification is a process in which low-cost, physically deteriorated neighborhoods experience physical renovation and an increase in property values, along with an increase in wealthier residents who typically replace the prior residents.IntroductionJohannesburg, also known as Egoli is...
Fear In South Africa943 words - 4 pages Cry, the Beloved Country, a book by Alan Paton, deals with the thematic struggle...
Apartheid in South Africa856 words - 3 pages Apartheid, the Afrikaans word for “apartness” was the system used in South Africa from the years 1948 to 1994. During these years the nearly 31.5 million blacks in South Africa were treated cruelly and without respect. They were given no representation in parliament even though they made up most of the country. It was not until 1994 when a black man named Nelson Mandela came to power in the South Africa congress. Once elected Mandela removed all...
Apartheid in South Africa2552 words - 10 pages Origins of Apartheid In the seventeenth century, South Africa was colonized by Dutch and British imperialists. In response to British domination, Dutch settlers made two colonies: The Republic of the Orange Free State and Transvaal. Dutch descendants became known as “Afrikaners” or “Boers.” In the early 1900s, Boers discovered diamonds on their land. This led to a Britain invasion and sparked the Second Boer War, which lasted three years. ...
Ecotourism in South Africa1515 words - 6 pages South African ecologists currently face many challenges relating to the conservation of biodiversity and the growing economy. Excessive hunting and land development, as well as unemployment, all remain growing concerns for this struggling country. Jan-Hendrik, a South African who made contact with us, stated, “South Africa has lots of social and economic problems because most people are poor. To get them to middle class requires the economy to...
Investment in South Africa1223 words - 5 pages Caltex plant was established in South Africa in 1977 after the owners decided to expand its operations in South Africa. The construction of the plant brought controversy over the interested parties, there were two dimensions of the utilitarian benefits of the Caltex plant, and there were violations of the justice and of moral rights whereas on the other side there were possible benefits to the South Africans. The plant setup was helpful in that...
Adolescence in South Africa1729 words - 7 pages In this essay the concepts of sensitive periods and critical periods are going to be discussed, and critically evaluated in regards to identity development amongst South Africans. In doing so one should also take into consideration South Africa’s historical context. The period of Adolescence is when individual undergoes a set of physical and psychological changes, known as the teenage years, and begins the progression to adulthood. In other words...
Apartheid in South Africa1347 words - 5 pages Nelson Mandela helped bring an end to Apartheid in South Africa because he was a believer in basic human rights, leading both peaceful and violent protests against the white South African Government. His beliefs landed him in prison for twenty-seven years, almost three decades. In doing so, he became the face of the apartheid movement both in his country and around the world. When released from prison in 1990, he continued to honor his...
Apartheid in South Africa.818 words - 3 pages Bringing Apartheid to an EndApartheid ? What do think that word means? Well in the Afrikaans language it means separateness. It was a cruel way of separating people. Four different groups were formed from this new law. These included Black, White, Mixed, and Asiatic. Some groups were treated better than the others. Example of that was be whites and blacks. Whites were treated more superior while the blacks were treated inferior....
Rape in South Africa787 words - 3 pages Rape is a very serious crime, which happens far to frequently in our country, often going unnoticed. Rape is always terrible, but even worse when it is committed against children. It is essential that the coming generations know what rape is, how to deal with it if they are ever affected by it.If the comments from the youth in the cartoon are true, South Africa will then continue to feature high up on the sexual offences list. You...
Institute for Security Studies (ISS) researcher Chandre Gould says she has been interviewing men in South African prisons in order to try to understand “the problem that, I think, bothers most of us”.
That problem is: what is it that causes people to turn to crime and violence? We know that it’s not just poverty, because poorer countries than South Africa do not have to deal with similarly acute crime epidemics. “Inequality”, similarly, seems too simplistic an answer.
In a quest for greater understanding, Gould’s research has seen her interview convicts who have been sentenced to prison terms for multiple crimes, at least one of which was violent in nature. “From that, I have come to see more clearly the factors that lead to men following lives of crime,” she says.
These factors invariably start very early. The loss of a parent or caregiver often features; more critical is the failure of parents to properly engage with infants and children. Gould found that many of her interviewees had experienced violence in their childhood homes. “Most were alienated early on from people and structures of authority,” she says.
Elmarie Malek, head of general paediatrics at Tygerberg Hospital, says there is abundant evidence to support the idea that early childhood can be critical in shaping a later propensity for crime or violence. Exposure at that time to what experts call “toxic stress” can have a significant negative impact.
Malek describes toxic stress as “strong, ongoing, unrelieved activation of stress in the absence of the buffering role that a caring adult plays”. This stress affects neural structures and can quite literally change brain architecture.
Such stress, Malek says, can be the effect of extreme poverty; neglect; abuse; or mental health problems on the part of the mother, such as depression or alcoholism. She emphasises that this is not just a problem associated with poverty: it could also apply to mothers who are isolated due to violent partners, parents who are very young, and parents who suffer from low self-esteem.
When very young children are continuously neglected, deprived of caring engagement and subjected to stressful environments, the brain areas responsible for learning and reasoning are affected. Lower confidence at school follows as a result, and behaviour can start to be affected. Such children begin to be classed as “problematic”.
“It sets in motion a whole chain of events that can become an ongoing downward spiral,” Malek explains. “There is definitely a link between the science around brain development and outputs for risk for criminality, anti-social behaviour and mental health problems.” Not every child who is exposed to toxic stress will become a criminal, she says, but that initial “dose of adversity” can significantly increase the risk.
Malek says that the need for children to grow up in stable and engaging environments can’t be overstated: spaces where in which there are at least one caring adult available on a long-term basis to create a solid bond with the infant and respond to its cues. Such an adult does not have to be the child’s parent; it could be a grandmother, other relative or non-related caregiver.
“We need to all be investing in everybody’s children,” Malek says.
Among the policy implications for the link between toxic stress exposure and later criminality are the need to screen pregnant families early on to identify those who may be at risk, Malek says. More education is needed about the importance of early childhood development, and the fact that the brain reaches 80% of its potential in the first two years after birth. Malek suggests greater attention also needs to be paid to the issue of paternal and maternal work leave, to give parents the financial space to spend this crucial early time with children.
From a government funding perspective, Malek believes the weight needs to tilt towards early childhood development, rather than education much later down the track. “Economically, we’d do better placing the emphasis on this early time,” she says.
Malek stresses the fact that an inter-sectoral approach is necessary to tackle these matters, and she says there are processes under way within the government to look at this. Gould is on the same page. She thinks, for instance, that our discussions about crime focus responsibility too heavily on police. Police Minister Nathi Nhleko would no doubt agree with relief. Presenting this year’s crime statistics to Parliament, Nhleko described crimes like murder as a “social problem” which need to be dealt with at a “multi-disciplinary level”.
Gould believes that there are fundamental problems with the way the country engages with the crime statistics each year – including the fact that it’s left up to the police to present the figures.
“This reflects the belief that police are both responsible for all types of crime, and can solve all types of crime,” she says. Gould believes the release of crime statistics should be an inter-departmental task, drawing on the Departments of Health, Social Development and Basic Education, to name a few.
“[Crime] is a problem we need to face holistically, and not just leave up to the police,” Gould says.
When it comes to the police, she suggests that what is measured in the statistics needs to change. “For as long as police are measured via reductions in crime, there is a perverse incentive not to report [cases],” Gould says. More emphasis should be placed on aspects like police response time, the quality of care provided by the South African Police Service, and the frequency with which completed, well-researched criminal dockets reach court.
Like Malek, however, Gould is convinced that the key to tackling South Africa’s crime problem may be paying closer attention to the manner in which infants spend their first days.
“If we don’t take care of those early years of life, we are just pushing the problem of crime to the next generation,” Gould warns. DM
Interested in getting involved with contributions to early childhood development? Visit the website of Cape Town Embrace.
Photo: Police officers advance to enter mens hostels after xenophobic violence in the area overnight forced foreign shop owners to close their shops for fear of attack in Actonville, Johannesburg, South Africa, 16 April 2015. EPA/KIM LUDBROOK
- Rebecca Davis
Rebecca Davis studied at Rhodes University and Oxford before working in lexicography at the Oxford English Dictionary. After deciding she’d rather make up words than define them, she returned to South Africa in 2011 to write for the Daily Maverick, which has been a magnificilious decision.
- South Africa